11 Comments
User's avatar
Larisa Rimerman's avatar

So beautifully expressed the tragic theme of the poem. I love: "The sky is full with empty promise of heaven." Remarkable note about two people, "Only one had thought /We are friends."

The last four lines of the last stanza logically repeat the theme of the poem and the image of the chipped teacup, broken compact, reflecting a rye smile is devastating, for me.

Expand full comment
Themes and Deviations's avatar

I know if I get a comment from Larisa, that I’ve done something beyond my fully conscious intentions. Thank you. I hope it’s clear enough that the rye refers to whiskey (the corruption of rye) as well as malevolence. That the perpetrator is still present at the scene, and that the perpetrator may be us, the witnesses. It’s so hard to know what gets across when using so few words. I don’t know any poets but the ones I’ve met here and the dead who I read. Your comments are invaluable and I very much appreciate them and you.

Expand full comment
Mahdi Meshkatee's avatar

Arthur, this is heartbreakingly poignant, and so dear to my heart. Sometimes I think how by thinking about the marginalized we are marginalizing a whole lot, and I can never quite catch myself running where margins no longer matter. If that makes sense!

🕊️

Mahdi

Expand full comment
Themes and Deviations's avatar

Mahdi my friend, Yes!! I have trouble sorting it out too. My response to Larisa’s comments absolutely apply to your comments. I never know what gets through because by the time I post I’ve read and edited the poem dozens of times or more. By that time, I hardly know what I’m aiming at; just feeling my way through language.

Expand full comment
S y l v i A 🌞 K a l i n A's avatar

What a lovely contemplation on the nature of the evidence of existence and its inevitable dissolution.

Expand full comment
Themes and Deviations's avatar

Thanks so much Sylvia. Always a pleasure to hear from the thoughtful crowd.

Expand full comment
James Wood's avatar

Yes!

Expand full comment
Themes and Deviations's avatar

Wow, that was fast.

Expand full comment
Paul Wittenberger's avatar

We never know if what we write “gets through,” Arthur, or if the words we use and how we feel about them is shared by others.

Expand full comment
Themes and Deviations's avatar

Thanks for those words Paul. You’re so right. I only know that after reading it and rereading it countless times, no words or phrases demanded changing. So long as they put up a fight we stay in the ring. I only give up when they give up. I suppose it could be said that we fight to a draw.

Expand full comment
Paul Wittenberger's avatar

I just trust readers to understand. If they don't understand, I'll try again. As Sam Beckett said, "Fail Better"

Expand full comment